Opinions on grading please

Started by rollycoins, January 12, 2018, 12:33:22 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

rollycoins

Hello there. Just wanted to see what others thought this $1/10c mule might grade. I got it about a year back noodling. Also, I've got a 1934 half-penny that I got at a local coin shop and I'm really clueless about grades etc. So opinions will help place my feet in the right direction with some benchmarks to look at. Thanks in advance and apologies if some images are less than ideal as I've reduced the number of pixels to fit into 1mb. 

Year 2000 $1/10c Mule:







1934 Half Penny:




ausproofs

Bit hard to grade with the pics, may be post some high resolution pics. Based on what I can see, I would say the $1 is XF45 to AU 50 or so and the penny MS 62BN ... That's a guess at best ..
Collecting coins is not about having the best, but loving what you have ...

stevo1962

I'd say about AU50 for the mule and maybe up to AU53 for the halfpenny.The photos are a bit too soft
to nail it down
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

rollycoins

Thank you ausproofs and stevo! I'll try to get sharper pictures ASAP. It is quite hard to work with the 1mb allowance. Maybe I will try an external link.

rollycoins

Here are higher resolution versions of the penny. That's the best I can go with 1mb. 

You can right click on the images and select open image in new tab and zoom in further. Thanks once again!




stevo1962

Much better and I think I'll stick to my original assessment
It\'s not about who you know it\'s about what you know

ausproofs

Okay, that is better ! AU58 to MS60 for the HP.
Collecting coins is not about having the best, but loving what you have ...

frenc11

Quote from: 'stevo1962' pid='113731' dateline='1515710459'I'd say about AU50 for the mule and maybe up to AU53 for the halfpenny.The photos are a bit too soft
to nail it down

i agree with stevo1962

rollycoins

Thanks everyone. I'll try to get the mule up once I have the time!

wwwww

I suspect that 1/2D has been cleaned, need to see in hand to be sure but if it hasn't been it looks around AU53.